The bustling New York City subway system that transports millions daily has grappled with decades of incidents involving accidental falls and intentional harm from train users. Discussions have been ongoing about numerous trial projects, such as the high-tech fare gate system experiencing "piggybacking" issues.

However, a popular pilot program New Yorkers have been requesting for years in an effort to overhaul the 110-year-old train shed is the fitting of platform doors (PDs). These physical barriers separating platforms from tracks have been gaining traction worldwide for their potential to safeguard passengers.

The Global Rise of Platform Doors

Also known as platform screen doors (PSDs) or platform edge doors (PEDs), platform doors are full-height barriers installed at the edge of subway platforms to create a physical separation between passengers and the tracks. These barriers offer various benefits:

• Enhanced Safety: PSDs greatly minimize the risk of falls, whether unintentional or deliberate, thus fostering a less dangerous environment for passengers.

• Improved Climate Control: Creating a barricade between the platform and tracks helps improve station climate control to maintain desired temperatures on platforms.

• Reduced Congestion and Smoother Flow: PEDs can contribute to smoother passenger flow by eliminating the need to wait for gaps between arriving trains.

Countries Leading the Platform Door Revolution

While New York City embarks on its pilot program, some Asian and European countries are already PD pioneers. For instance, the Paris Metro in France, known for its efficiency and extensive network, has successfully deployed extensive PDs in its bustling Paris Metro. Such widespread adoption has contributed to a safer and more controlled passenger experience.

Renowned for its cleanliness and technological advancements, the Tokyo Metro boasts platform doors in most stations. It showcases the successful integration of PDs into a high-volume, technologically advanced subway system. The Seoul Metro has also adopted PDs in many of its stations to enhance passenger safety while contributing to a disruption-free subway system.

Singapore's Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) system boasts platform doors across all stations to ensure a controlled boarding and disembarking experience across the entire subway network. These pioneering countries offer invaluable insights and practical examples for New York City as it navigates its own platform door pilot program. Learning from their experiences can guide the potential wider PD application in the city's subway system.

The Pilot Program Takes Flight

Despite its vastness and undeniable cultural significance, the New York City subway system has long faced safety concerns. Recognizing the potential of PDs, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) announced the launch of this platform door pilot program in February 2023. Installations are planned to take place in three strategically chosen stations: Times Square (7 line), Third Avenue (L line), and Sutphin Boulevard-JFK (E line).

Times Square's high passenger volume stemming from millions of tourists and commuters makes this one of the busiest stations that can benefit from testing PDs in a high-traffic setting. Also, its intricate layout with multiple entrances and mezzanines can pose challenges to passenger flow and safety. PDs could improve navigation and reduce the risk of falls.

Third Avenue's L line has very narrow platforms that often create accessibility concerns for passengers with disabilities. PDs could offer a safer and more comfortable space for all riders. The station is also undergoing some renovations, which makes this an opportune time to experiment with PD integration as part of the station's modernization efforts.

As a gateway to JFK Airport, Sutphin Boulevard sees an eclectic mix of passengers with varying levels of familiarity with the subway system. PDs could enhance safety for these riders, especially those unfamiliar with platform etiquette or unwritten rules that contribute to a safe and smooth flow of passengers on the subway platform. What's more, the station's location in a densely populated area allows for exhaustive data collection on the effectiveness of PDs in different demographics.

Platform doors represent a promising step toward enhancing safety and commuter experience in the New York City subway system. It's a pilot program that aims to achieve the following objectives:

• Assess Effectiveness: The program will evaluate the effectiveness of PDs in preventing accidents, improving safety, and decreasing incidents at the selected stations. It achieves this by comparing data on accidents, incidents, and safety-related delays before and after the outfitting of PDs. All these will determine if there is a significant reduction in these occurrences, thus indicating improved safety and efficiency.

• Evaluate Operational Feasibility: This phase gauges how well PDs integrate with the existing subway infrastructure to ensure compatibility with different train types and operational efficiency. Compatibility is important because it ensures that the platform doors align perfectly with the train doors upon arrival. Such an alignment is crucial for preventing accidents, minimizing delays, and allowing for the smooth and efficient boarding and exiting of passengers.

• Gather Public Feedback: The program actively seeks public feedback on passenger experience with PDs by collecting valuable insights on usability and overall impact on the commute. These assessments give the MTA knowledge that informs all decisions regarding the broader installation of PDs in the NYC subway system.

While the NYC platform door initiative is just a pilot program, its success will determine future implementation across the entire subway network, according to Mayor Eric Adams. There are also ongoing discussions about the program's cost-effectiveness compared to other potential safety measures.

For example, increasing police presence patrolling platforms and trains may deter crime and provide faster response times. Further, talks are underway of employing track intrusion detection technology systems that immediately warn operators of people (or objects) falling on the tracks.

Prioritizing Work-Life Balance in Manhattan

As New York City works toward creating a secure space for subway riders, finding a safe, clean, and private workspace is just as important. Broadway Suites appreciates this need and offers pristine, fully enclosed office spaces in Midtown Manhattan that let you focus on your work with complete peace of mind. Our commitment to safety extends beyond the subway system, since public areas are meticulously sanitized severally by a dedicated in-house cleaning staff. In addition to a full-time, onsite management team, we offer flexible lease options to give you the best value for your money. Contact Us today to inquire about a Manhattan office space and start your Broadway Suites experience.

all images are licensed under Canva